Does anybody know what the plot hole was in goblet of fire that jk rowling had to fix. Jk rowling responds to major harry potter plot hole. Harry potter plot holes created by the movies screenrant. Harry potter and the order of the phoenix is the longest book in the series, at 766 pages in the uk version and 870 pages in the us version. Through death, he had been given new life and brought new life to those who he left behind. Biggest plot holes in harry potter business insider. Top 20 harry potter plot holes page2 out of 3 in cos. Harry potter has one huge plot hole you mightve missed huffpost. This is a plot gap simply absent from story not a plot hole. Harry potter fans have just discovered a massive plothole in the story. Unless youre feeling a bunch of harry potter nostalgia, i wouldnt recommend this book to you. This is a plot gap simply absent from story not a plot hole a istake surrounded by correct info. But as much as we love the series, we cant help but notice some of the glaring plot holes in both the books and movies. The plot hole that ate a mother and father theleaky.
As such, the creators of the movies never even knew that thestrals existed. Mafalda was lost as a result because the character was not carrying out the function she wanted it to. The quest for good is a function of human development. Still, here are some of the mysteries and plot holes in the harry potter universe. First, let me say that i love the hp series and i bow down to jo rowling and her ability to weave magical and multitudinous plot lines across thousands of pages. But in a 2004 interview at the edinburgh book festival, rowling maintained that this wasnt an error. A sternlooking witch asked the headmaster of hogwarts. Only harry has the power to change the course of events that have claimed all those he loved. The entire convoluted plot of goblet of fire is all an elaborate scheme to get harry to touch something. Does anybody know what the plot hole was in goblet of fire that jk.
Harry potter plot holes and questions explained time. Jul 17, 2009 so, what are some of the biggest plot holes you have discovered in harry potter. Harry potter goblet of fire plot hole filled greg ladens blog. Harry potter fans have just discovered a massive plothole.
This is the the biggest plot hole in harry potter indy100. Jul 16, 2017 harry potter fans have just discovered a massive plothole in the story. It was published worldwide in english on 21 june 2003. I think we can pretty much deduce from jos interviews that she came across some major plot hole partway through the book and she fixed it. With more than 550 million copies sold worldwide, harry potter is the bestselling book series that ever existed. Over the years, fans have put together a long list of discrepancies and theories from the books and movies. Posts alleging some kind of systemic prejudice against the op because they are adults that exclusively read ya. If there are answers weve missed, we would be more than happy to hear them. Some of these mistakes were fixed in later editions of the same book. T heres no denying that harry potter is one of the most magical series ever written, but even j. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter movies and books duration. Even with years of preparation, connecting the dots and mapping out which wizard is related to which muggle, its pretty much impossible. Itd have been a much safer optionand it would have saved their lives. Harry potter fans have just discovered a massive plothole in.
So, what are some of the biggest plot holes you have discovered in harry potter. The plot of the whole harry potter series is a very intricate thing with many twists and turns and mysteries. Also are there any more plot holes that people have picked up on. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Keep reading to see the biggest plot holes in harry potter. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone book plot hypable. The words were sorry were the very last thing he heard before taking one bold step through the veil. I will start off by saying some things though 1i would love it if you could play neville for my character. When turning a book series into movies, writers are bound to leave plot holes and unexplained events out.
Are there any plot holes in harry potter and the deathly. Its harrys first year at hogwarts but lord voldemort, the evil sorcerer, is determined to. Professor albus dumbledore declares he would trust hagrid with his life, so i. Thats why harry potter will always live in our hearts. Harry potter and the goblet of fire was published on 8 july 2000 at the same time by bloomsbury and scholastic. Is there a plothole in harry potter and the cursed child. Discover friendlier foreign women, social connection, authentic people and saner cultures, lower cost living, healthier food, greater freedoms, and more. Hole is a brilliant and driven detective with unorthodox methods, a classic loose cannon in the police force. I love the harry potter series, and i dont mean any disrespect to jk rowling or the books themselves. All we want to do is make sure that the discussion about these mistakes is being had. Apr 05, 2012 harry potter and the sorcerers stone book plot harry potter is not a normal boy. Whenever a big fan reads something accusatory regarding their prized movie or book, they get defensive.
Its one of many sources of frustration and conflict in their lives along with not. Read on for fifteen of the biggest plot holes in the series. I read it more like three spells that land you in prison for life. They actually have every mistake in the harry potter series listed in order by chapter.
Harry hole is the main character in a series of crime novels written by norwegian author jo nesbo. Yet in the end of the last book, harry is openly discussing the event with his son. Harry potter jk rowling harry potter fans think theyve spotted a plot hole in fantastic beasts 2 trailer. Here are 15 massive plot holes in harry potter that were never explained. They end up trapping it within a hole, in order to proceed.
We learn at an early age that some things are good for us and some are not. She missed her deadline for gof by two months because she had to rewrite a large portion of the book to fix that plot hole. Its not a plot hole, just sometimes fans need to give jkr some slack. We all know that jkr is a genius, but even geniuses slip up, and shes never afraid to admit it. Literally anything could be a portkey, but they decided to use the triwizard cup, rig the goblet of fire to choose harry as a fourth contestant, abduct and replace one of the hogwarts professors for the entire school year, make sure harry succeeds in all the trials and is. These lessons are ones in which we are taught through our verbal and physical interactions with caring adults. With the movies people will argue that a missing scene is a plot hole even if it isnt needed. With the release of harry potter and the cursed child, many potterheads were excited to jump back into the wizarding world. The 5 biggest plot holes in harry potter, as exposed by diehard fans. But even with these plot holes, i think we can all agree that harry potter and the sorcerers stone remains a classic a classic with bankrupt wandmakers and nonsensical sports, to. Cover the art for the cover of the original uk edition depicts harry at platform nine and threequarters wearing a. The 5 biggest plot holes in harry potter, as exposed by fans stylist. The book begins as voldemort, who had been told of the. Top 10 shocking differences between the harry potter movies and books.
Top 20 harry potter plot holes best, most, greatest of. Harry potter is thrown into a world that is not his own, where his parents are alive, and neville is the chosen one. Not only is the wizarding world strange enough to have only developed one sport, the single sport that they have makes zero sense. Harry, hermione, ron and draco are caught out late at night, and are forced to serve detention with hagrid in the forbidden forest. You can transform your life and solve your problems by leaving america for a better life and love overseas. Jul 17, 2018 9 harry potter mysteries and plot holes the movies left hanging duration.
Mistakes in the harry potter books harry potter wiki. Most common complaints in regards to harry potter are continuity errors, or otherwise characters actions. Jk rowlings fantasy series remains one of the most popular franchises ever conceived. Fans spotted this major plot hole in fantastic beasts, but jk rowling says its all part. However, after reading through the script, many fans were upset with how many uncharacteristic plot holes there were. Aug 09, 2017 while it is established in the goblet of fire that the unforgiveable curses require concentration and power madeye moody says. The fourth harry potter book, harry potter and the goblet of fire, is the true turning point in the series. There are moments in the harry potter series where they havent executed their best problem solving skills. So what are the biggest plot holes in the potterverse. Its beautifully crafted, charming, engaging, and generally just the best thing to come to childrens fantasy books in a long, long time. All of these plots will pertain around that 2 that being said, im willing to double on some of these plots, and the ones that. Discussion according to multiple sources, the reason goblet of fire is such a long book is because jk rowling realised she had written her way into a massive plot hole and had to go back and write her way out of it. Does anybody know what the plot hole was in goblet of fire.
Plot holes are much bigger errors than people seem to realise. Here are 15 harry potter plot holes everyone should be talking about. Mar 21, 2015 the iron trials is a cheap ripoff of harry potter. What was the plothole in gof that made jkr rewrite half the book. Its beautifully crafted, charming, engaging, and generally just the best thing to come to childrens fantasy books in. I dont think those are the only things you can end up in trouble over though.
Very difficult an enchanted stained glass window thats actually a door. According to multiple sources, the reason goblet of fire is such a long book is because jk. However, after reading through the script, many fans were upset with how many uncharacteristic plot. If you really want to go down the rabbit hole, theres always harry potter wiki to take up the rest of your day or possibly even your life.
Good in harry potter as defined through biblical texts. Harry potter and the numerous plotholes home facebook. All posts are my opinions and interpretations based on reading the harry potter books and interviews with j. A suit of armor plays a grand piano and when you sing along, the piano shifts aside. In fact, i dont think i would recommend it even then. The second inspector harry hole novel harry hole series book 2. When i first learned of thesterals as a reader in the fifth harry potter book, i thought this seemed like a major plot hole. The movie version of harry potter and the philosophers stone was released before the book version of harry potter and the order of the phoenix was released. I recently discovered that there is a widespread belief that there is a huge, gaping, plot hole in harry potter goblet of fire by j. Critics link the personality of harry hole to those of the famous literary detectives.
But even her magic is fallible, and the resulting mistakes can be kind of fun to sleuth out. Into the nothing chapter 1 megamatt09 harry potter j. Apr, 2017 harry potter and the cursed child spoilers. Jk rowling responds to major harry potter plot hole after. I am a huge harry potter fan and would do anything to attend hogwarts. Firenze, a centaur, tells harry that it is a monstrous thing to slay a unicorn, let alone drink its. Raised by his cruel aunt and uncle, and tormented by his bully of a cousin, dudley, he has resigned to a. Nineteen years after defeating voldemort, all was finally well. Dont just list off the ones from mugglenet or another hp fan site just share with us what you believe are the biggest plot holes or mistakes in your opinion.
Daniel radcliffe began acting when he was 6 years old, playing a monkey in a school play. Dec 21, 2016 jk rowling responds to major harry potter plot hole after being asked every week jk rowling has finally spoken out on a harry potter and the chamber of secrets issue shes seemingly. What, in your opinion, is the biggest plot hole in the. Mar 20, 2017 many have been addressed, but the explanations are unsatisfactory for the most part. Rowling is one of the best writers in the world, as she created a whole new universe that made potterheads dream that she was actually a wizard who didnt care about the international statute of wizarding secrecy. Harry sees a hooded figure drink the blood of an injured unicorn, which makes harry s forehead scar start burning. Obviously, jk rowling framed the story this way so that each books. Culture books news 21 insanely difficult harry potter trivia questions even diehard fans have trouble with. Young harry will turn eleven at the end of the month. Posts about the same six books over and over and over again. The series of harry potter is arguably one of the most influential stories of our time. By the time he was 12, he was an international movie star, taking on the role of harry potter in a series. But harry must now fight the demons of his past and his new future. Jk rowling responds to major harry potter plot hole after being asked every week jk rowling has finally spoken out on a harry potter and the chamber of secrets issue shes seemingly.
Top 10 massive plot holes in harry potter duration. This story features harry s first year at hogwarts, him making friends and facing challenges in the new and wonderful world. For many, it was their first and final midnight release of the series. The goto source for comic book and superhero movie fans. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading cockroaches. The biggest plotholes and inconsistencies in harry potter. Rowlings writing is so vivid and breathtaking that its easy to overlook the many plot holes in works like harry potter and the sorcerers stone, but lets face it. May 09, 2007 plot hole in harry potter and the goblet of fire. What are the biggest plot holes and errors in harry potter.
Because if that happened the goblet of fire would be a picture book that looks pathetic on your harry potter bookshelf. Rowling would patch it up in future books, online or in some other fashion. We acknowledge that plot holes, if were using the truest definition of them, dont really exist in the harry potter books or films. The second inspector harry hole novel harry hole series book 2 kindle edition by nesbo, jo. They could have been given the same protection as the dursleys. Perhaps the dependency on magic affects common sense. Would j k rowling have made a living as a thriller writer had she not have written. Rowling herself has admitted that the story has a few plot holes but while some of these. Top 10 cringe moments in harry potter movies duration. She said she nearly walked away from writing the rest of the series bc of a flaw in the book which she didnt notice until she had finished writing it. The fantastic world of harry potter is, without a doubt, absolutely incredible. Harry potter and the sorcerers stone book plot harry potter is not a normal boy. It shows us we should dare to hope, even in the darkest of times, and it shows us what true love and friendship is.